Defining railroading

2 December, 2007 at 11:31 am (definition, rpg theory) (, , )

Disclaimer: I think railroading is distasteful. My definition portrays it as negative.

Game master’s decisions are railroading when

  1. Players assume they can have an effect on a particular aspect of the game.
  2. There is no credible diegetic (fictional, in-game) reason for players to not be able to affect that aspect.
  3. GM’s decision negates or marginalises player input with regards to that aspect.

I think the first part makes railroading inherently bad and feel railroady to the players.

Example time.

  • A band of merry PCs must decide to go either south or west because they are at crossroads. Wherever they go, they shall encounter the same group of bandits. They have no reason to assume that there would or would not be bandits at either direction. Not railroading.
  • As above, but reliable sources tell that there is only one group of bandits and they prey on the south road. The group of PCs take pains to make it seem like they are going south, but actually go west. They spread rumours, check out that they are not bieng spied, etc. Still they face the bandits. This I would call a minor instance of railroading, unless the bandits had a good reason to go west and it is revealed to the players.

4 Comments

  1. njharman said,

    Good definition. But now I ask how does one avoid railroading?

    I don’t want to railroad, but I feel that I do. It’s in my nature as I’m more a story writer than DM. So, think up plots, encounters, situations that I consciously or unconsciously “force” my players into.

    A piece of advice I read but find very hard to do in practice is “Don’t think about the ending.” That is create the conflict and leave resolution to the players.

  2. Cogito, ergo ludo. said,

    […] December, 2007 at 5:18 pm (rpg theory) (railroading, resolution, rpg theory) In my previous post, I defined railroading. Before that, I listed some heuristics for choosing to use or not use the game’s resolution […]

  3. To not railroad « Cogito, ergo ludo. said,

    […] December, 2007 at 8:51 pm (game mastering) njharman asked how to avoid railroading. For the purpose of this post, I assume reader does not want to railroad […]

  4. Railroading, once more | Cogito, ergo ludo. said,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: